Where to Buy Sapphire Engagement Rings in Boston (And What to Look for Before You Choose One)

If you’re searching for sapphire engagement rings in Boston, you’re not alone - sapphires have quickly become one of the most loved alternatives to traditional diamond engagement rings. They’re durable enough for everyday wear, naturally unique, and available in a range of colors that feel personal (from classic deep blue to modern teal, green, and even peach tones).

At Laura Preshong, we specialize in gemstone engagement rings in Boston, offering ethically sourced sapphires and handcrafted settings designed to last a lifetime. Whether you’re just starting to explore sapphire rings or you already have a specific color in mind, this guide will walk you through what to look for - and how to find the right sapphire for your style, lifestyle, and budget.

Why Sapphire Engagement Rings Are So Popular Right Now

Sapphire engagement rings are having a moment, and for good reason. Sapphires are one of the most durable gemstones used in fine jewelry (making them ideal for everyday wear), and they offer a look that feels more expressive and less traditional than a classic white diamond.

Many of our Boston clients choose sapphires because they want a ring that feels:

  • Meaningful and unique (no two sapphires look exactly alike)

  • Colorful but still timeless

  • Ethically sourced

  • Durable enough for daily wear

  • Customizable in a way that feels personal

Sapphires also pair beautifully with both modern and vintage-inspired engagement ring designs - so whether your style leans minimal, nature-inspired, romantic, or bold, there’s a sapphire ring that fits.

What Makes a Sapphire a Great Choice for an Engagement Ring?

When you’re buying a sapphire engagement ring, the most important factors aren’t just size and color - it’s also about durability, quality, and how the stone will wear over time.

Sapphires are made for everyday wear

Sapphires rank 9 on the Mohs hardness scale, which means they’re one of the hardest gemstones used in jewelry (second only to diamonds at a 10). That’s a big reason sapphires are such a popular choice for engagement rings - they can handle the daily bumps and normal wear that comes with living in your ring.

They come in more colors than most people realize

While blue sapphires are the classic choice, sapphires also come in:

  • Teal sapphires

  • Green sapphires

  • Light blue or icy blue sapphires

  • Purple sapphires

  • Peach and champagne-toned sapphires

  • Yellow sapphires

  • Color-shifting sapphires (depending on lighting)

  • Split color sapphires (also called parti-color)

This range is a huge part of why people searching for a sapphire engagement ring in Boston are often looking for something more custom and personal than a traditional diamond.

Where to Buy Sapphire Engagement Rings in Boston

When you’re shopping for a sapphire engagement ring, the best place to start is with a jeweler who can help you compare sapphires side by side - because color, tone, and sparkle can vary dramatically from stone to stone.

At Laura Preshong in Boston’s South End, we work with clients locally and virtually to create sapphire engagement rings that are beautiful, wearable, and truly one-of-a-kind. Our approach is designed to make the process feel exciting and straightforward, whether you want to shop a ready-to-ship ring or build something custom from the ground up.

When clients come to us looking for sapphire engagement rings in Boston, they’re usually looking for one (or more) of the following:

1) Ethically sourced sapphires

Ethical sourcing matters, especially when you’re choosing a stone that will represent such a meaningful moment. We partner with trusted, vetted vendors so we can offer sapphires that align with our values, including options for clients who prioritize traceability, responsible sourcing, and overall quality.

2) Guidance on color and quality (without pressure)

Sapphires are all about nuance. Two stones can be the same size but look completely different depending on:

  • saturation (how rich the color is)

  • tone (light vs deep)

  • hue (blue vs teal vs green)

  • sparkle and “life” in different lighting

Seeing stones in person (or through guided virtual comparisons) is one of the biggest advantages of working with a Boston jeweler who specializes in custom sapphire rings.

3) Custom design options that feel personal

Many people searching for sapphire engagement rings in Boston want something that doesn’t look like everyone else’s ring - and custom design is the best way to get there. From setting style to diamond accents to band width, a custom sapphire ring can be tailored to your exact aesthetic. We can also customize any of our existing styles.

4) Settings designed for real life

A sapphire engagement ring should be beautiful, but it should also be secure and wearable. We design with long-term wear in mind - including stone security, comfort, and durability - so your ring feels as good on your hand as it looks in photos.

Custom Sapphire Engagement Rings in Boston: How the Process Works

One of the most common questions we hear is: “Do I choose the sapphire first, or the setting first?” The answer is - either works. Our process is flexible, and we’ll guide you based on what feels easiest. That said, we typically recommend starting with the setting first, since it helps narrow down the right sapphire shape, size, and overall look from the beginning.

Here’s what designing a custom sapphire engagement ring typically looks like:

Step 1: Choose your setting

Starting with the setting helps you define the overall feel of the ring and ensures your sapphire is chosen to fit beautifully and securely. Your setting affects everything from how the sapphire looks on the hand to how protected it is for everyday wear.

Some popular sapphire engagement ring setting styles include:

Step 2: Choose your sapphire

Once we’ve landed on a setting direction, we’ll help you find the perfect sapphire to match it. Some clients come in knowing exactly what they want (“teal sapphire, oval shape, medium depth color”), while others want to compare options in person - either way, we’ll guide you through the details that matter most. You can explore our Misfit Sapphire and Colored Gemstone collections.

We’ll narrow down the right sapphire based on:

  • color preference (blue, teal, purple, etc.)

  • shape (oval, round, emerald cut, cushion, pear, and more)

  • overall budget

  • sparkle level and face-up look

  • lifestyle and durability needs

Step 3: Final details + finishing touches

This is where your ring becomes truly yours - things like:

What Color Sapphire Should You Choose?

Color is the heart of a sapphire ring, and it’s also the part that’s most personal. When clients are shopping for sapphire engagement rings, we often see a few favorites:

  • Deep blue sapphires: classic, timeless, high contrast

  • Teal sapphires: modern, moody, unique in every lighting

  • Green sapphires: earthy, unexpected, elegant

  • Light blue sapphires: airy, soft, bright on the hand

  • Peach sapphires: warm, romantic, subtle color

The best way to choose is to compare stones in natural light - and to think about what you want the ring to feel like every day. Some people want dramatic contrast, while others want a sapphire that reads more neutral until the light hits it.

Are Sapphire Engagement Rings More Affordable Than Diamonds?

Sapphires can be a more budget-flexible option than traditional natural diamonds and are fairly equivalent to lab-grown diamonds, but pricing depends heavily on the stone’s:

  • color and rarity

  • size

  • origin

  • cut quality

  • number of inclusions

What we love about sapphires is that they allow for a wide range of styles and budgets - from minimalist solitaires to fully custom designs with diamond accents - without losing that “wow” factor.

If you’re shopping for sapphire engagement rings in Boston and want help balancing budget and design, we’re always happy to walk you through options.

Sapphire Engagement Ring FAQ

Are sapphires durable enough for everyday wear?

Yes - sapphires are one of the best gemstones for engagement rings because of their hardness and long-term wearability. With a well-designed setting, they’re a beautiful choice for daily wear.

Do sapphire engagement rings sparkle like diamonds?

Sapphires sparkle differently than diamonds. They can be incredibly bright, but the “fire” and rainbow sparkle you see in diamonds will look more subtle in sapphires. Many clients love that sapphires feel rich and dimensional rather than ultra-flashy.

What shapes look best for sapphire engagement rings?

Some of the most popular shapes we see are:

  • oval sapphires

  • round sapphires

  • cushion sapphires

  • emerald cut sapphires

  • pear-shaped sapphires

The best shape depends on your style and the specific sapphire you choose.

Can I customize a sapphire engagement ring in Boston if I’m shopping from out of state?

Absolutely. While we love seeing clients in our Boston gallery, we also work with many clients virtually. We can guide you through sapphire options, setting styles, and custom design details remotely.

Visit Laura Preshong in Boston’s South End

If you’re wondering where to buy sapphire engagement rings in Boston, we’d love to welcome you into our South End gallery. Whether you’re looking for a classic blue sapphire, a unique teal sapphire, or a fully custom engagement ring designed around a one-of-a-kind stone, our team is here to help you find something you truly love.

The best way to choose a sapphire is to see it in person, compare tones side by side, and talk through the details that matter most - from color and durability to setting style and long-term wear.

Ready to start?
Explore our sapphire gemstones, engagement ring settings, or book an appointment to begin designing your custom sapphire ring in Boston or online.

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Back to From the Bench